It's sad to suspend the project after spending several hundreds of crores. Good luck to TATA as other states are lined up for red carpet welcome. It's shame on WB govt, mamatha and last bengalis.
Mamta can pat herself on the back for not allowing TATAs to get their Nano car plant going in Singur and for forcing them out of WB. She & WB CM can pat themselves on the back for an operation they can call successful but with the patient dead ! Ratan TATA should have taken this decision long time back instead of expecting a miracle. It should be an eye opener for other industrialists wanting to go to WB or Kerala. The people of WB deserve this for not standing up to Mamta for destroying their rare employment opportunities. It also shows the mental bankruptcy of the WB CM in resolving disputes speedily. Obviously, vote banks are more important than adminstering the state effectively.
We, who are working outside Bengal & India also know what mother land is. We always expect & dream that we will serve for our Mother land but no hope for this type of dirty politics...............
Re: What a decission !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Brat on Sep 02, 2008 09:24 PM Permalink
That's the prize of being to democratic. People of Bengal just hope, we see the end of Mamata and his Party of asses.
Tata will benefit from moving out of WB in the long run. Even if mamta would not have done all this, there would have been at least 10-15 strikes every year in WB. If you count all these the loss would have been much more in years to come.
Re: This will help the Tatas indirectly
by kaladhara saralaya on Sep 02, 2008 09:19 PM Permalink
What 10-15 strike, it should be 100s minimu. Look at Kerala, the mother land of strikes.
HOW MANY OF YOU URBAN PATRIOTS WILL GIVE YOUR METROPOLITON HOUSES FOR THE CITY DEVELOPMENT? IF YOU WANT TO MAKE PROFIT PAY AT LEAST TEN TIMES OF THE MARKET RATE.ARE THE TATAS ARE HOLYCOWS JUST WANT TO BUILD THE FACTORY FOR THE COUNTRY. THEN IT WAS EAST INDIA COMPANY NOW IT IS INDIAN COMPANIES THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE
Re: TATAs TATA
by kaladhara saralaya on Sep 02, 2008 09:26 PM Permalink
Mind you, most of the Metro people are from village background. It means, metros are encroched upon by Villagers of India. They enjpoy metro culture and that is the reason whhy industry should move to villages rather than concentrate on metros. But not upon agri land.
Re: TATAs TATA
by SIDDHARTHA PAL on Sep 02, 2008 09:21 PM Permalink
I will give my everything, if both me and my surrounding are benifitted for it. We all know the emotions. So you are saying, if your son or daughter get a better living for your sacrifice, you are not ready to do it for them right??
Re: Re: TATAs TATA
by Ananda Sen on Sep 02, 2008 09:33 PM Permalink
if you give every thing for benifit of your surrounding, then you do not remain in that surrounding so how do you or your sons and daughter get benifit of that changed surrounding? Why fertile land of Singur? why not the barren land of Bankura, Birbhum, or Purulia
Re: TATAs TATA
by Pave Noormi on Sep 02, 2008 09:22 PM Permalink
If you start thinking like that, how will the industry develop in this country? It is the duty of the government to facilitate land for new industries, and Tata has done that only. It is the failure of West Bengal Govt and no need to blame Tatas..
Re: TATAs TATA
by Ananda Sen on Sep 02, 2008 09:24 PM Permalink
you are absolutely correct. There are vast trac of barren, unfretile land in several other districts of West Bengal, why those lands are not utilised for industrialisation,taking away agricultural land is adding to the global food problem.
dont worry TATA ji you are warmly WELCOME to Uttarakhand.......let Mamta search another ISSUE..... Bengalis are unfortunate to have Mamta....Mamta has no mamta for Bengalis.
Re: mamata ki jai
by Amit Manyarya on Sep 02, 2008 09:25 PM Permalink
Bongs will remain Bongs! Nobody on Earth can change these lazy, lathergic, self-proclaimed intellectuals...
Re: Re: mamata ki jai
by Ananda Sen on Sep 02, 2008 09:38 PM Permalink
I do not agree, Bengal needs industrialisation but correct place to set up the industry has to be found out. In Singur we will get a car at the cost of rice.
Re: mamata ki jai
by Guest on Sep 02, 2008 09:23 PM Permalink
Hey Mr. Intellectual, not only you don't need Tata but you need leaders like Mamata and you got it. It is so unfortunate that Bengal which gave so many great leaders to the country is producing leaders like Mamata Banerjee who knows only to oppose any thing that is in the interest of Bengal and Bengalis. Well your choice Bengali Babu. Your Govt. also opposed computerization and see what happened. Other states went ahead and are far better today than what Bengal is. Noe your Govt. is begging with the IT companies to open office in West Benagl. but it is too late.
Re: mamata ki jai
by Sam Nath on Sep 02, 2008 09:28 PM Permalink
Mr. Sandeepan, Are you fool? Any party is better than Commies what to speak of Mamata.
Tata is the captain of indian industry since indewpendence. He is the best entrepreneur India had ever since independance. No nonsence man, no politicking, no greed and top of that sincere and simple to the core. He is the world leader too. Just think of Reliance .. just manipulators of share holders money and making their family rich. The only daughter hs wealth of 80 Billion $!. The entire problem is created by the Cummi Govt. In the first place they shouldn't have acquired a fertile land for industry. Thed available agri land should not be used for any other purposes other than for cultivating. Industries can go any where but not agri. When our national policy is against aquiring of any agri land by perosns other than agriculturitsts, why WB Govt has aquired agri land (that too fertile land) for ind=ustry. WB Govt must compensate Tata for this huge loss. Mind you, Tat's money is nothing but share holders money. WB has cheated these share holders. Tata is only a custodian.
Re: WB - Cumunist Govt must compensate Tata.
by samarth raut on Sep 02, 2008 09:17 PM Permalink
small correction in first line...I think think TATA is captain of Indian Industry since the time WELL BEFORE independence.
Re: WB - Cumunist Govt must compensate Tata.
by kaladhara saralaya on Sep 02, 2008 09:20 PM Permalink
Yes you are right. But then it was English People who had upper hand in every thing.
Its a menace created by Mamta in order to get her vote bank for upcoming election.Her political ambition has cost Bengal much more than what Mamta would have gained.Tata in Singur would have given a new dimensio to that place.Industralisation would have changed Bengal face and the people whose imagination has been captured by Mamta's words would have known how much important is Tata at Singur.I would erge Mamtaji to stop using people at Singur for her political ambition and behave more responsibly and just give a minute as Indian about what Tata means for Singur---
Re: Bengal Chaos
by kaladhara saralaya on Sep 02, 2008 09:17 PM Permalink
WB doestn't deserved to be uplifted by industrialisation. This Cummunists are experts in creating public unrest. Instant strikes , protests are the face of this Cummis. We have Kerala and WB with Cummi at helnm of affairs. But most mayalayalees have settled elsewhere.
