By doing this people like Mamata Banerjee would take wb to great heights.
It is unfortunate that some of the landowners have not been paid bcoz of technical reasons but this is not the way a big project of reputed Indian form like Tatas should be dealt with.
Re: Mamata Banerjee will take west bengal to great heights
by Kanth on Sep 02, 2008 10:05 PM Permalink
with her cloths down, she can take everybody on high.. lol.
Re: TATAs are welcome to Bihar..
by K Narasimha Rao on Sep 02, 2008 10:02 PM Permalink
This is actually a very good suggestion. Moving equipment from WB to Bihar is not a big deal, I guess
Re: TATAs are welcome to Bihar..
by SK2007 on Sep 02, 2008 10:12 PM Permalink
TATA's must modify the car into a boat. Good idea to have flexible mobility.!
Re: Re: TATAs are welcome to Bihar..
by vinay thakur on Sep 02, 2008 10:23 PM Permalink
TATA started their career in Bihar only!Now state is called Jharkhand!TATA have most of their property and investment in this state and grown from here!Half knowledge is most dangerous thing!
As TATA has pull out of on going Nano project in Singur. It is really a harsh on our politicians, how they clear the matter and after so much time has passed why the somebody agitate for its personal interest. Now nobody will come to W.B. for an any investments
Re: It is a disappointing for West Bengal
by Bullish on Sep 02, 2008 10:03 PM Permalink
Watch out for what Miss Dharna does from tomorrow does she has the guts to face the Nepali Gorkha Morcha in Darjeeling as they are trying to take millions of acres of lands out of Bengal? No no.
Mamta BAnerjee, Jyoti Basu and the leaders of their kind who don't have vision for next 1 day , are controlling the State's Future in their hand. The only way they can possibly strive is by encashing on the vote banks of have nots, and so it's in their POLITICAL favour of people remaining Poor, State not progressing so that they can survive their political career even though it means no career for the entire state.
Whatever the Communists' mistakes, Mamata cannot disown her role (a nmajor one) in the quitting decision of the Tatas. Whatever sympathies I had earlier with her, they are totally gone now. Mamata's obstinacy, peevishness, grumpiness, narrow-mindedness, egotism, whimsicalness, utter lack of statesmanlike qualities, and most thoughtles and silly agitation putting every stumbling block in the way of the Nano, the first cheapest unique car of India - contributed solely to the unceremonious exit of the Tatas from West Bengal. Instead of fighting it out with the CPM, and instead of demanding for a higher compensation etc for those who owned the disputed 400 acres of land, she unnecessarily took her ire on the Tatas. 400 acres is too small an affair considering the nature of the small car project. Mamata's stock has gone down abysmally and she will go down in history as an anti-industry boor and as a low level and illiterate politician. West Bengal and India would never forgive her for her most negative role.
Re: Mamata to blamce
by Anil Kumar on Sep 02, 2008 10:16 PM Permalink
Most of the Indians stand by her and poor farmers..including me!! 400 ACRES OF LAND FOR YOUR INFORMATION IS A LOT LOT of lkand..around 5000 people can live on that kind of land and they don't want to give that land!!who are we to judge?
So the blame should go to communists in what ever way you look at it.They are the cause for this problem..and should be thrown out odf India.Yes i don't like communists:)
Re: Mamata to blamce
by Atreya Sarma Uppaluri on Sep 02, 2008 11:11 PM Permalink
My dear Anil Kumar, Even one inch of land also is valuable, per se. The only thing is, when you have to decide whether the 400 acres of land is going to give further prosperity to the State or the unique pioneering car factory that too from an industrial house with impeccable credentials. If your logic is accepted, then no goverment can acquire any amount of land for any public purpose. The car factory, its ancillaries and other trades and business depending on it would give employment for many more times the 5,000 that you have quoted. And you seem to miss a thing: that I said, Mamata should have fought for a higher compensation to the farmers. Most of the Indians have never been with her, whatever her antics. She has been wasting her energies on non-priorities, with the result the only possible bulwark against Communists has collapsed, thanks to her blind opposition to the car factory, just because it is happening in the CPM rule. Also, pl note that Mamata has never been near any number that has been close to getting power in WB. Moreover, she has been changing her allies too often, showing her political fickleness. She has, badly-sadly-unfortunatey missed her course.
Re: Mamata to blamce
by K Narasimha Rao on Sep 02, 2008 10:04 PM Permalink
Well, a beautiful description of Mamata's character in your paragraph. Hope she reads it.
Re: Leadership
by K Narasimha Rao on Sep 02, 2008 10:05 PM Permalink
I saw a report on Zardari, sometime ago. Probably we should do it on Mamata as well. I am not sure, but the web blogs may work to the advantage of the good guys in trouncing the bad guys atleast in the cyberspace.
Re: I wish Nano productions fails
by . on Sep 02, 2008 09:59 PM Permalink
traffic jams can occur due to other vehicles also. y only blame only nano. merely bcoz, its cheap but high on technology?
Re: I wish Nano productions fails
by newgamian on Sep 02, 2008 10:04 PM Permalink
This car shouldn't be produced anywhere in india in view of the infrastructure in the cities. An ambitious but illogical project has been applied brakes. Blessing in disguise. Hope this becomes a permanent fullstop for the tatas greediness
