There are many states and Governments ready to help Mr Tata to relocate his venture. It is disgusting to see politics being played and tolerated by people when we talk of Globalisation and liberalisation of 21st century. This will a send right message for others also who wish to create problems for development.
There are many states and Governments ready to help Mr Tata to relocate his venture. It is disgusting to see politics being played and tolerated by people when we talk of Globalisation and liberalisation of 21st century. This will a send right message for others also who wish to create problems for development.
Re: Is TN India's detroit
by Human on Sep 03, 2008 12:08 AM Permalink
Fool do you ever visit Detroit, You never understand there English.
Comparing to you like convent educated no grammatical English, tamilians are much better and well cultured. In India how many states did you visited. Tell them to talk in English You can make a novel. First correct your mind set.
1. Tata Nano is not only an Rs.1 Lac Car, nor its only the cheapest car in the whole world.
2. Its an Challenge. Its an GIFT to masses of india by TATA.
3. TATA NANO an example of Patriotism.
4. TATA NANO a car being built by TATA with almost no profit at all. YES, trust me, if you do calculations TATA will not be able to make even Rs.10,000/- profit on each tata nano.
5. BUT Ratan TATA is doing all his best to give INDIANS this car.
6. RATAN TATA said, i'll give it to INDIA, whatever i have and what ever i earn.
7. This shameless MAMATA and Mindless CPM are ruining West Bengal.
Re: The art of blackmailing excelled by Ratan Tata
by Human on Sep 03, 2008 12:16 AM Permalink
You are correct
In workers point of view, tata is the worst ever i seen. Including TCS, There managers are inhuman aged rascals get paid and enjoyed and press workload to there workers, not even appoint employees. Every Tata Employee has a sad part, which they are not ready to revel or bring out openly.
People Say Tata are ethical.. But Chanakya has said " Business and ethics dont go hand in hand". Tata or Narayan murthy of Infosys may wear mask of ethics but truth is every corporate in India and all over world are grown on basis of manipulation and unethical work.But unethical means varies from corporates to corporates.Reliance may do more,tata may do less-- But every corporate does unethical work.Talking about bribes even Tata have paid bribes- So no ones saint in corporate world. Now let us come to the moot point :
First, let your own land or house or property gobbled up in the interest of an industry and
then comment. This is the most fertile zone of WB. Some distance way in infertile land other
industries are coming up without any difficulty. Ratanji made several mistakes which he might not acknowledge but remains answerable to shareholders and making the industrial climate state of WB, and the country hostage first with his follies and then with veiled threats. He is trying to equate Nano with India iteself which is a dangerous thing to do.First, let be Nano on road for few years, perform and then we start clapping. Now onto his mistakes
Re: The Inside Truth - Nano,Tata's Ego & Harsh reality
by Sushma Sengupta on Sep 02, 2008 11:51 PM Permalink
(i)Why did he only depend on only overwhelming majority of CPIM in state of WB, not bothering to talk to prinicipal oppositions or local people as in politics things might change. Did he believe that CPIM is ruling Bengal for 30 years and will continue to do so for another 30 and he doesn't need to bother??ii) underestimating opponent - in nano naming function he said that he wanted to name it 'Buddha', 'Mamata' and 'despite Mamata' thinking the battle is already won. One can make fun of his friend if he doesn't mind but wasn't it prematured to make fun of Mamata (iii) Ratanji very boisterously said that some other car manufacturing co. is instigating trouble in Singur, he has proof and would reveal it at appropriate time. When will that time come now that he is deciding to leave Singur, eating his own words?iv) what if supreme court says the method in which a fertile, irrigable land was acquired without owner's consent in the name of public interest and given to a private profit making company is illegal? did he ever look at legal, constitutional issues? Tatas have many other manufacturing facilities in WB doing very well and nobody opposes it.
Re: Re: The Inside Truth - Nano,Tata's Ego & Harsh reality
by Sushma Sengupta on Sep 02, 2008 11:52 PM Permalink
Why is it here? One should have the patience to understand the problem and act like a narcisist.
What is then the way out? The middle path proposed is to retain 600 acres as required solely by tata motors to be there where it is, remaining 400 acres required for ancillary units to be moved to few km away in a low lying land which is not as fertile. It may increase the cost of the car by approx. 5000 INR. Is this Ratanji's ego that 1 lakh is 1 lakh and if it
is 1.05 is the ego is hurt or Nano becomes unprofitable? Which other car is competing with it in that price range? It is time accept mistakes and apologise to the people of Singur as well as shareholders of Tata Motors for the mistakes made by him and move forward or if the chorus, JLR acquirer's ego is so much inflated let the job be given to somebody else.I request the readers to take note of the fact how people in and around Singur oerwhlmingly
voted for Mamata. These were the places where CPIM was ruling. Why is it so? In a democracy you should learn to respect peoples wishes. Unfortunately, very few of us believe in democracy and mostly feudal in nature. We want to decide what is good for others. We worry about youth not getting job if there is no industry because our kids are to serve in industry? Will we stop eating? Who will cultivate land and where? Industry can shift to an infertile land but cultivation cannot. We want others to sacrifice. How much sacrifice we ourselves have made?
Dear Mr Tata, Its very tragic that u have to leave bengal before the commencement of the project the dream Nano Car... this is the high time for you to decide the corporate social responsibility of TISCO also and start shifting its HQ from Kolkata to Ranchi... if u don't do so and DVC, CCL. BCCL all other starts doing it you will be in trouble again.... there is more than 100 years relationship b/w you and the people of jharkhand..... now the awareness is coming to this poor state also... so you can't fool people for longer time.... benefit of all activities related to an industry should be shared by the people who suffers for it.... I think you have to think on this point and open one centre of TCS in Ranchi and Jamshedpur as soon as possible.... now u can't complain about the infrastructure also... Please think over it... and take some decision as soon as possible....
Re: Request To Ratan Tata
by Ayan Nandy on Sep 03, 2008 12:00 AM Permalink
Dear Rishi,
not only TCS, but most of the software companies in India are going to stop onsite projects. The clients of these s/w organizations are interested in profits which will increase by cutting costs. The costs will go down if people in India work in multiple shifts.
Think logically and you will understand that Ratan Tata holds no magic wand. He is just a plutocratic ego bomb ready to explode on the soft targets of India - the confused semi-educated people whose only aim in life is to get a job.
See how many local people of Uttaranchal got jobs in Tata's Voltas plant in Panthnagar. Look at the working conditions there; not a single fan for the mostly contractual workers in an AC & refrigerator factory. Isn't that a shame?
Please dont be so optimistic, your bubble of hope can blast any time.
Re: Re: Sushma Sengupta needs *you*
by Ayan Nandy on Sep 03, 2008 12:03 AM Permalink
Those who have no point to make are left with the weapon of personal attack. If you had the guts to search for the truth, you would have tried to counter the points raised by Sushma.
