ANY THING AND EVERY THING IS POSSIBLE WITH TECHNOLOGY TODAY AS YOU MUST SEE THE GULF COUNTRIES NOW ADAYSTHEY HAVE RAINS AFTER THEY HAVE STARTED NEW WAYS OF IRRIGATION METHODS AFTER TAKING INFORMATION FROM THE EXPERTS THEY ARE ALSO PLANTING TREES AND VEGETABLES IF U KNOW PHIR APNA INDIA TO SONE KI CHIDIYA HAIN ITS NOT A DESERT STOP CRYING OVER SPILLED MILK AND THINK WHERE TELSE WE CAN START PLOUGHING WITH NEW METHODS AND GET THE GOVT TO GET THE MONEY FOR THE NEW WAYS OF DOING THE IRRIGATION OTHER THEN GETTING THE POOR OX TO POUGH THE FIELD.
Cars like these will pose severe environmental,space and fuel problems. I request the government to intervene and ban projects like these once for all.
RE:BAN TATA NANO AND OTHER CARS LIKE THESE
by tamil on Jul 31, 2008 03:17 PM Permalink
ban is not a wise decision.. rather make strict safety rules.. which will make cars like nanao 800 off the road & more live wil get saved
RE:BAN TATA NANO AND OTHER CARS LIKE THESE
by Nilarun Ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 01:39 PM Permalink
hopeless thinking..don't think people around you..think in rural area..where to go hospital need 1 mile to walk..
When we think of a business group which has contributed ALL-ROUND for development of India, ONLY ONE name comes to our mind - TATAs. Way to go - we are proud of you!
RE:Tata - we are proud of YOU
by rex on Jul 31, 2008 01:07 PM Permalink
you are right ambani ko ginti mein mat lena they are the hopeless lots only concerned about making towers for themselves. never thinking about their employees reall pain
RE:Tata - we are proud of YOU
by Kajal Sethi on Jul 31, 2008 02:04 PM Permalink
If you are not aware of unannounced donations made by Mukesh Ambani, please refrain from commenting. Some people do not want publicity for their donations. As to Anil Ambani, ask Samajwadi party.
RE:RE:Tata - we are proud of YOU
by Kajal Sethi on Jul 31, 2008 02:10 PM Permalink
If the creation of largest refinery in the world is NOT counted as development of India, then please write here WHAT IS development of India?
RE:Tata - we are proud of YOU
by R.K. Singh on Jul 31, 2008 02:25 PM Permalink
it never is.......... it is business projection only by the a businessman who knows india has most cheap labour in the world.
and how much educational, children helps, elder help, orphange, AIDS assistance, Cancer assistance, rural development projects are handled by Ambanis(both of them are just r*s(*als ) ... and for your info all of the above mentioned projects are handled by TATAs.
They do the donations to politicians.... reason they need their assistance to stay in the game otherwise remember what happened to Reliance fresh in Lucknow)
GET THE PLANT TO THANE MAHARASHTRA SO THAT WE COULD SURVIVE YOU WILL GET LOTS AND LOTS EDUCATED PEOPLE TO WORK FOR YOU THAT THE KISSANS OF SINGUR. YOU DONT EVEN HAVE TO PAY THEM FOR THE ACCOMADATION TRANSFERS AND VICE VERSA WE ALSO HAVE WELL CONETED RAILWAY AND AIRPORT AND PANVEL IS NEARBY WHERE ANOTHER AIRPORT IS COMING TATA'S ARE WELCOME.
RE:PLEASE GET THE WORK TO THANE MAHARASHTRA
by R.K. Singh on Jul 31, 2008 02:28 PM Permalink
:) .......... sure he hasnt.... Maharastra is only meant for AMBANIS
Communists ideology in India is based on Anti-industrialization. All policies/statements by every Communist leader(except Buddhadev) for 50-years is against Industry. It was foolish of Tata to think that Leftists will change.
RE:Communists are Anti-industrialization
by sugata paul on Jul 31, 2008 01:22 PM Permalink
Dear Sanjeev, it is not leftist but super rightist great Mamta's Trinamul congress creating all short of nuisance against not only Tata project but aginst three proposed steel plnat,one thermal power, two national highway, one petrochemical project etc etc etc.
Its saddest time of my life at this point . Mamta trying to emulate what CPIM has done for decades. Stop progress of Bengal .Jyoti Basu should be tried as war criminal for spoiling futures of millions of bengal citizens .Now CPIM after all this years have understood their mistake , trying to change , but alas Mamta encashing on popularity vote by pushing back Bengal to another 15 years of backward society. Nano is pride of whole India , its achievement will be a turnaround for Indian economy, leave about Bengal.Service industry ( BPO ) alone cannot resurrect ailing Bengal economy. Breakthrough innovations like Nano will rewrite history . In Gods name unable to understand why are we not whole heartedly supporting this pride project of yours. Centre now is playing all sorts of game , didnt disclose nuclear deal to public openly & now giving local support to Mamta , to stop Nano production in Bengal , shift it elsewhere . My appeal to PM , why not extend full support to TATA's for such achievement , so that we become a force to recon with in the world with Nano . The way they have supported and helped Reliance to become what they are now ..GIANT CONGLOMERATE .
RE:Mamta making same mistake as CPIM
by SANJEEV KUMAR on Jul 31, 2008 12:49 PM Permalink
Actually, mamta is giving the same pill to Bengal-leftists, that the central CPI-M leaders like PrakashKarat are pursuing in rest of country. Bengal-Leftists can't pursue HYPOCRACY- support industry in bengal and Oppose it in the Rest of India.
Tata should shift the factory to haryana.singur can be utilised by the commies for making country made guns/bombs,which will be in demand for the coming elections
RE:shift the factory
by palash ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 04:46 PM Permalink
u dont seem to read papers . the leftist want the factory there. Reactionary Mamata banerjee and her rightist are opposing it
I dont understand how come the so called intellectuals cannot think on long term, if all the agriculture lands are been acquired for industries India will no longer be a agricultural country. even after 60 yrs of independence so many families still survive coz of this lands, if the comapanies really want to take the country ahead use the waste land not agriculture lands.In the current situation the peopel are not having enough food and if the fertile lands are used like this then the day is not far when there will be no difference between indians and somali.All the people who feel roti is the priority among "roti, kapada aur makan" should oppose acqusition of agriculture, fertile lands all over India, as these acqusitions are done by the brainless polticians who donot bother about the people or the country.
RE:Use other barren land for Industrialisation
by rahul jaiswal on Jul 31, 2008 12:50 PM Permalink
dear sudha,
but we should not forget that without starting new company / factory, india cannot become a developed country. And tata is not using this land for their own profit, they are making the car for lower middle class people and i think it is good attempt.
RE:Use other barren land for Industrialisation
by vikranbir nagra on Jul 31, 2008 01:22 PM Permalink
Please understand.. the amount of land needed for industry is way smaller than that needed for agriculture.. we need both no doubt and they surely can coexist...
nearly all of land in India is under agriculture so to start any industry land needs to be acquired. This will not affect agricultural output of the country as the land is pretty small w.r.t that under cultivation.
We need development and the farmers who need to be relocated must be sufficiently compensated. If we fail to compenste them sufficiently we must not aqcuire their land. But the irony is even when compensation is proper, petty politics make it impossible to aqcuire any land
RE:Use other barren land for Industrialisation
by shubasrikrishna on Jul 31, 2008 12:47 PM Permalink
What has India gained by being agricultural economy. The returns per acre is nothing when compared to insustries. Please go and see how China has developed. Other than depending on rain and suiciding due to debts, the life of a Indian farmer has been pretty difficult. It is time we moved out of our agricultural mindset. The displaced people will be well of economically working in the car factory at Singur.
RE:Use other barren land for Industrialisation
by Nitin Borkar on Jul 31, 2008 12:52 PM Permalink
Sudha,
I fully agree with your thoughts. Only the thing which I don't know is..whether land in Singur is fertile or not. If it fertile, no way we sholud use for industrialization. With this we shall starve for food after some upcoming years and shall be depending on other countires for food. Same thing is happening in Maharashtra. We have agriculture minister with his back support many projects are coming on the fertile land near Pune and Raigad districts. Why they can't develop the areas like Ahmednagar and Sholapur where over the long time rains donot come and agricultural development do no happen? They should certainly use that part for industrialization.
RE:RE:Use other barren land for Industrialisation
by akhil kapoor on Jul 31, 2008 01:08 PM Permalink
If farmers get good value for the sale of their land....then why not......moreover most of the land in india is fertile for agriculture.....then where will the industries go...........Chinese economy was almost equal to Indian economy in 1965.....however today they have left India far behind......industrialisation is a major factor in it
its a bad event which is happening backed by political & business rivals ( Rahul Bajaj & Maruti Suzuki)... for west bengal & for india...
Mr Osamu Suzuki, chairman of Suzuki Motor Corp be ready for the competition in the auto market... not at press rooms making cheap comments on TATA Nano...
RE:unethical business rivals
by rex on Jul 31, 2008 12:57 PM Permalink
baja is scrap unka pulsar 150 cc is also scrap dont buy their things they dont have resal value
The location where Tata builds it's so called dream project was an excellent fertile land for agriculture. There are lots of unused lands nearby. Actually CPI(M) wants to teach Singur people a lesion for not voting for them in the last assembly poll. Why state government acquired this land forcibly with the help of an old law for a private company? Why the state government decides the price of the land and there was no control of the land owner. Guys you will only understand if your land (from where you earn your livelihood) taken by government at a paltry price set by them. The so called industrialization in West Bengal is a complete hoax. There is a dirty nexus between Tata and CPI(M). How many crores of rupees taken by Alimuddin Street from Tata? Tata is facing a daunting task to bring its one lakh car due to high inflation and preparing for excuses.
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by rocky chan on Jul 31, 2008 12:33 PM Permalink
Mamata di Jindabad....you should continue your protest so that the comeing generation would face no rice, no price problem....
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by Nilarun Ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 12:41 PM Permalink
wat amar singh done in didi's house is now breaking news.shame Mr. Singh,u don't have any choice
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by rex on Jul 31, 2008 12:47 PM Permalink
west bengal isa communist state like kerala and i dont think anything good can happen there till the communist are there to rule
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by Nilarun Ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 12:23 PM Permalink
Everyone can give his/her expert comment.For any successful industry there must be convenience for tranportation.When W.B govt. invites all party for discussion they didn't have any time.now when this project about to complete they are creating problem.These men r against of W.B,against of TATA,against of INDIA.Get them out with "lath" in back from INDIA
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by Avik Chatterjee on Jul 31, 2008 12:31 PM Permalink
I know that I told the truth and that causes a burning chili in your ass...you CPI(M) cader.
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by Nilarun Ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 12:36 PM Permalink
u r talking in the language of fool people who r insisted to burn their own house..u don't want developemnt of west bengal.u people only care about ass..Get out of W.B
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by NITIN on Jul 31, 2008 12:45 PM Permalink
Mr.Ghosh i have seen from the long time All the left parties rules governments kept their ruled states far away from Globalisation and industrialisation. Now they come to know that there is no alternative other than industries and globalise investment so they r urging towards companies, but other parties are working on their (left)'s strategy now to push back them. That's why once's rich capital of india calcutta and state WB are poorest now.
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by Nilarun Ghosh on Jul 31, 2008 12:55 PM Permalink
ur statistics is completely wrong..In per capita income W.B is among the top states in india.Can u tell me one state who is rich?for ur kind info. China was also far from global industrialisation but still china is developed country..CPIM tries to global investment in w.b last decades but before that did u heard any non communist parties in w.b created agenda in their aprty for gloabl investment?
RE:Why Singur is chosen for this damned project
by rex on Jul 31, 2008 12:45 PM Permalink
wont this people who land has been taken away for a small sum get job there if they are educated or not educated till they or their kids get in the main stream.
