Discussion Board
Watch this board

Total 5 messages Pages | 1
Speculation, cartelization and hoarding
by S Sen on Feb 08, 2007 01:22 PM  Permalink 

There is no doubt the Indian real estate market is highly overvalued and that there is an impending disaster round the corner. Investors and speculators beware!

Let us accept that this sharp increase in real estate prices throughout India, is not because of increased demand which many analysts, whose livelihood depends on real estate, want us to believe. Speculation is a major driving force. But there is more in it than that meets the eye. Cartelization is another major contributing factor. Big builder have formed cartels in many cities and artificially jacked up the price. The third contributing factor is hoarding. Some unscrupulous businesssmen have cornered strategically located prime properties. Such properties are typically located close to IT parks, SEZs, railway stations and airports.

All of those show that we Indians have not changed during last 15 years of liberalization. I thought after 15 years speculation, cartelization and hoarding had become things of past and that MRTP has lost relevance in today's new, liberalized India. I also thought that the average Indian business man had changed his manipulative business partices after being exposed to the global economy for a fairly long period.

I was so wrong!

Today's property speculators should be dealt with as firmly as we used to deal with food hoarders of 60's and 70's. India is an highly overpopulated country. Land should be treated as a limited natural resource and should be protected and regulated like food grains, water, radio frequency, minerals etc.

The government should wake up and take some action. It is common knowledge that all the political parties are making quick money out of this artificial boom. That is nothing new in India and let us not get too moralistic about that. But the same politicians should realize that they have to survive politically too. Real estate prices, if left unregulated, may soon turn into an election issue.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Real Estate disaster awaiting soon!
by Dont Worry on Feb 07, 2007 03:08 PM  Permalink 

These real-estate prices have gone up beyond the reaches of even upper middle-class people unless they have assets thru hereditary means or if they have overseas income sources. Only young married executives where husband and wife both are making good money are investing in real estate without thinking about the cost or returns etc%u2026just to avoid heavy income tax. This bubble is going to bust soon as people who really need house will stay away from purchase and those who have bought it for heavy price may not able to get good returns (thru rent) or they may find lending rates as very high to sustain such heavy investment for a very long periods. Since most of the real estate prices are not offering Value For Money, since the market force is playing on the price hike, it is bound to fall significantly. I can only pity those who have invested in Apartments by paying Rs80 Lakhs or Rs 50 Lakhs etc%u2026

    Forward  |  Report abuse
A well written article
by KN VENKATESH on Feb 07, 2007 02:08 PM  Permalink 

A good one to depict the current situation

http://ideasmoney.blogspot.com

    Forward  |  Report abuse
kambrish@rediffmail.com
by Ambrish Kapoor on Feb 07, 2007 11:23 AM  Permalink 

very tru and very gud article!!!! appreciate rediff for this.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Investing in Real estate
by vijay kumar vaid on Feb 07, 2007 10:01 AM  Permalink 

I agree it is bubble which may bust any time.There is limit to what real estate prices can go.With banks increasing interest rates the taker will be less.In Mumbai alone there are large number of flats lying vacant as they were purched by investers to make quick buck. Today the situation is the builder is willing to sell with all kinds of insentives and the invester is left high and dry.One has to be careful before buying DLF share even though he is comming up with a bonus issue.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 5 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message