IT APPEARS TO ME THAT UNNECESSARY SO MUCH LIMELIGHT IS THROWN ON THESE IIMs AND BUSINESS SCHOOLS; THIS MAY DUE TO BRAND BUILT BY THEM; MAY BE BIASED.
STUDENTS FROM OTHER TOP NATIONAL INSTITUTES LIKE ICWAI, ICAI ETCL. ARE NO WAY LESSER THAN MBA GRADUATES FROM IIMS. SYLLABUS AND PERCENTAGE OF PASS RESULT MAY BE ANALYSED WITH THESE IIMS.
THE CONTRIBUTION WHAT LESS LIMELIGHTED INSTITUTES AND ALIKE ARE MAKING IN THE ECONOMY MAY BE ASCERTAINED.
DUE TO EXTRA HYPE ONLY FRESH MBA FROM THESE SO CALLED TOP INSTITUTES ARE EXCELLENTLY PAID COMPARED TO OTHERS EVEN WITH HIGH UNIVERSIOTY AND PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATION.
I FEEL INDUSTRY MAY CONDUCT AN INDEPEDENT SURVEY ON THE CONTRIBUTION OF NEW MBA FROM THESE INSTITURES AND OTHERS SAY FINANCE FROM ICWAI/ICAI/ICSI, MAY RETHINK ON THE HIGH PAY PACKET ALONE TO FRESH MBAs WITHOUT EXPERIENCE; WHICH IS NOT AN USUAL FEATURE IN THE DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
This kind of survey is definitely biased and doesnot refelct the actual rankings.Lot many goood institutes do not participate and refrain from money tactics.Only private institutes are the ones who are best suited for this kind of survey as they definitely entertain OUTLOOK. Apart from this whats the credibility of OUTLOOK.lets first figure out that.....
Business schools in india are going to create future leaders. Managers, who are going to promote products, services and creat income for people, company. And it will help create many jobs for many indians. Bus. School are like temple, where the wish of india to be a rich and powerful nation is gonna fulfilled. So they have to maintain very high standard. and its possible only when students, mgmt both understand how imp. is their role in our future. Otherwise its about just getting certificate.
Business schools can help corporates grow but not the economy or a country. Managers(MBA's)can help corporates corner higher market share for their companies but in no way can contribute to the overall economy. Unlike popular belief like that of yours they cannot create income but help concentrate the income with corporates which are the fittest.
The world will not see a fundamental change if all this managers from the business schools disappear from the face of the earth.
Teachers, researchers and people from all walks of life with a sense of social responsibility keep the world going in the forward direction. However, these people are the humble beings who struggle to keeping things rolling in the right direction and the so called Business school graduates only grab these towards themselves and corner the glory and the moolah.
In reference to your statement on Managers promoting products and services, it doesnont matter if the a company X and its managers cease to exist, company Y will just do what X was doing with no problem. Its not like the world will end.
India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is hardly given its due !!!!!
I feel that merit is harldy a consideration in our society unlike USA or Europe. Merit is not given respect,whereas success by hook or crook is the name of the game. Even crooks with lot of manipulation and sycophancy with very average brain can surpass all in our society.This success is accepted as intelligence and luck. Our standards of success have become perverted,today underworld don may command more power and respect than an university professor. Surely ,in todays India a don is more successful than an university professor. It is shame that Amitabh Bachhan prefers role of Gabbar than Jay. It is reflection of falling standards of our society. Except Naraynamurthy's, Premjis.,there are countless CEO's who are more successful ,not because of their talent but because they succeed on the basis of treachery & a good deal of unfair means. There are several IIT'ians who are CEO's in USA ,however they would do far worse if they were to work in India. India a country of one billion crabs who pull each other down, even most prestigious IITs/IIMs are no exceptions . See people of one billion can not win a single gold medal in olympic,it is a shame.
The best & most popular game of cricket,India is ranked 7th in ODI . This game is played not even by 10 countries of the world.
Do you not think enjoy pulling each other down??????Why ,
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by random on Sep 17, 2007 09:53 AM Permalink
And your point is ??? There are a billion people in our country and you have to stand against the competition to survive, which is never bad. And dont make nonsense statements like "There are several IIT'ians who are CEO's in USA ,however they would do far worse if they were to work in India.", and how is ever your comment related to this article??
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by Pratyush Jha on Sep 15, 2007 12:04 PM Permalink
And what you are doing is ...???
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by on Oct 16, 2007 06:04 PM Permalink
there r some how always like other wife and ur in one of them.IN 100 MOST INFULANCEAL ASIAN 14 ARE INDIAN AND RATAN TATA TOP THE LIST u state the example of olampic that indian didnt get a gold medal but seeing so many amarican in dope test including grat marian jones we get to know how they get so many gold medal for u V.ANAND IS TWO TIME WORLD CHAMPIAN HOCKEY TEAM WIN GOLD IN OLAMPIC 8 TIMES,Dola Banerjee won the 18th Golden Arrow Grand Prix tournament at Antalya,Jayant Talukdar won silver medal at the junior World Championship in Britain; first Indian archer to win the gold medal in the FITA Meteksan Archery World Cup; world no. 2 in individual recurve event,archer Limba Ram World record and gold medal in the 1992 Beijing Asian Championship; Tarundeep Rai Won gold medal in the 2004 Asian Grand Prix Archery Championship at Bangkok; member of the Indian team that finished fourth in the 2003 World Archery Championship in New York;Anju Bobby George National record holder in long jump; won bronze medal at the 2002 Manchester Commonwealth Games; won gold medal in the 2002 Busan Asiad Games; became the first Indian athlete ever to win a medal in a World Championships when won bronze at Paris ,Gold in the 800 meters in the 1995 Asian Track and Field Meet in Jakarta;Jyotirmoyee Sikdar gold medals in 800 m and 1500 m events in the 1998,Milkha Singh Won the 200 and 400 meters events in the 1956 Tokyo Asian Games; won the 400 meters at the 1958 Cardiff Commonwealth Games; broke the O
RE:RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by on Oct 16, 2007 06:08 PM Permalink
, Badminton Aparna Popat Won the national women's title consecutively for eight years; won the Women's Singles in the French Open, Paris in 1998; won silver at the 1998 Kuala Lumpur Commonwealth Games; runner-up in the World Junior Championship at Denmark in 1996;Prakash Padukone Won the national senior title consecutively for nine years; won the gold at the 1979 Commonwealth Games; won the Danish Open and the Swedish Open; won the prestigious All England Badminton Championship in 1979, P. Gopichand Won the All-England Open Badminton Championship in 2001; reached the finals of the Indian Open, a grand prix event,Billiards Pankaj Advani Winner of three world titles in billiards and snooker; in 2005, became the first player to complete a grand double by winning both the points format as well as the time format titles in the IBSF World Billiards championship,Ashok Shandilya Won two golds in billiards at the Asian Games held in Bangkok in December 1998,Michael Ferreira Won the World Billiards Championship four times; in December, 1978, created history by becoming the first amateur to make a 1000 point break in billiards,Geet Sethi Winner of eight world titles - five World Professional and three IBSF World Billiards Championships; featured in the Guinness Book of World Records for being the first amateur in the world to compile the maximum 147 break in Snooker; made a break of 1276 in the 1992 World Professional Billiards Championship, a World Record; Wilson Jones,Won the Nation
RE:RE:RE:RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by on Oct 16, 2007 06:11 PM Permalink
. Golf-Jeev Milkha Singh First Indian golfer to become a member of the European Tour; won the Volvo China Open,Jyoti Randhawa Won the Hero Honda Masters in 1998 and 1999; Indian Open in 2000; in 2002 won the Singapore Open and became the first Indian to win the Order of Merit title in Asia,Shooting Abhinav Bindra Made a junior world record score of 597/600 in 2001 Munich World Cup and won bronze; gold in 2002 Manchester Commonwealth Games; became the first Indian shooter to win a World Championship gold,Jaspal Rana Won a gold at the 46th World Shooting Championship (Junior Section); twice equaled the world record score of 590 points in Centre Fire Pistol event;Swimming-Bula has become the first woman in the world to have conquered the seven seas in five continents. She earned this distinction in August, 2004 by crossing the Palk Straits from Talaimannar in Sri Lanka to Dhanushkodi in Tamil Nadu in approximately 14 hours.Mihir became the first Asian to swim the English Channel when he crossed the Channel in 14 hours and 45 minutes. The year 1966 proved to be a watershed for Mihir Sen as he swam across the seven seas of the five continents in one calendar year. In April, braving high tides and shark-infested waters, he swam across the Palk Straits, the sea between India and Sri Lanka. In August, he crossed the Straits of Gibraltar between Spain and Morocco and one month later became the world's first man to swim the Straits of Dardanelles.In the same calendar year, Mihir als
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by on Oct 16, 2007 06:13 PM Permalink
Mihir also swam across the Bosphorus and the Panama Canal. ABOVE ARE JUST THE FEW EXAMPLE WE INDIAN HAVE ACHIEVE MUCH MORE BUT TO SEE THAT YOU HAVE TO COME OUT OF UR WELL
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by S Narain on Sep 15, 2007 12:02 PM Permalink
cntd.. Do you not think enjoy pulling each other down??????Why ,we can not be like Australia ,which is smaller than UP!!!!! Just think about it.!!!!
RE:India is country where mediocrity is celebrated than Merit is given its due !!!!!
by surya prakash thatavarthy on Sep 15, 2007 01:11 PM Permalink
Mr Narain,
If you have no work go s--- off instead of putting senseless mails like this.
By the way Australia is a continent and India is a country. There is no geographical comparision in size between Australia and UP. Australia is atleast 20 times the size of UP. The population might be less though. The problem is educated people like you and me waste their time on stupid things like this and do not contribute to the society and talk nonsense.
How does IMTGaziabad fair among the Private BSchools in acadamics and placements? Does the top recruiters in Finance visit IMT? iF THE SURVEY DOES NOT FIND IMT in top positions repeatedly under Industry interraction/interface, why does not IMT improve on that ? Does the evaluation actually takes place ojectively? I have my own doubts?
RE:IIPM
by Antistupidity on Sep 17, 2007 02:01 AM Permalink
Oh IIPM - avoid them like the plague. Almost all the hype about IIPM is generated by them alone through their advertisements. Stay far away from them if you are planning either an MBA or looking for fresh MBAs to recruit for your company.
RE:IIPM
by kirankumar pedada on Sep 17, 2007 03:51 PM Permalink
U have misunderstood..S I accept that it created hype..but its a good institute..Faculty is good and many more things are good..i feel very sad that its not listed even among the top 50.Its better that many and many among the listed schools...I am a student of IIPM...and also topper...I got settled well and working along wiht IIM guyz..and my frens also got placed well...
RE:IIPM
by Ponera Konra on Sep 15, 2007 10:48 AM Permalink
buddy it is not ranked in the top 50 private schools. if u are studying there,im sorry, dont feel bad, maybe a few years from now it will reach top because of the investments in advertisements and movies that Mr.Arindham Choudhri makes.
