Hi All.. I was watching Aus Vs Ind match and the umpiring was in worst stage.Ganguly out for a grounded catch...umpire no clue wheather out or not.Ponting signaled to umpire as out and the umpire raised his finger.It is an Amazing umpiring by the great aussie captain Ricky Ponting...Both Umpire and Ponting should be removed from International cricket for this cavarfly work..this win is not win..cheated win combinely done by the umpires and Aussie team..
RE:Ricky Ponting skipper or umpire ?
by ria jain on Jan 06, 2008 01:42 PM Permalink
actually umpire ki zarurat hi kya hai???... jab decision lene hi ponting aur othr aussies ko hai to kyun na icc paise bachaye umpires ko hata kar aur ponting ko hi khada kar de vahan!!!! wat say???
RE:Ricky Ponting skipper or umpire ?
by Mani Mani on Jan 06, 2008 02:03 PM Permalink
i dont know hindi.I hate this this bleddy umpire Steve Buckner and Benson.They shud be sucked.Steve is always against India..Aussies not a great team.Ponting is not having the qualities for the captain.He is not having the attitude,character for a captain and obviously have seen in the ground..But Our captain shown the character,attitude in the Ground.I am proud of kumble.
as we heard match by fixing by players in the past....this is something like match fixing by umpires...they are not even thinking wether the batsment is out or not...they just favoured ausis irrespective of out or not out
Well there you go. That is all over for India. Right from the word go, they were up against a stiff Australian side but when they took the field, they had other opponents to face as well. On Day 1, Australia were 50 odd for 2 when Ponting was given not out by umpire Mark Benson. The Indians overcame that and had the Australians reeling at 134 for 6. Some time later, Symonds was adjudged not out by umpire Steve Bucknor, again a clear edge which only Bucknor was unaware of. Some more time later, the third umpire joined the party, a stumping appeal was turned down against Symonds with his foot on the line. He went onto score his career best score and with another decision going in favour of him, a stumping appeal not even referred to the third umpire by Bucknor. Then comes the Indian innings, Jaffer was bowled off a no ball but it went unnoticed. Then came the Aussie second innings, Hussey was caught behind but given not out. He was out lbw some time later but given not out. Then came the final innings. Rahul Dravid was given out caught behind when the ball was nowhere close to the bat, Ganguly was given out despite Clarke having grassed the catch twice and Dhoni and RP Singh were at the wrong end of marginal decisions. It might seem like a case of sour grapes but had so many decisons not gone against them then perhaps India would have ended up with a 200 run first innings lead. Decisions go wrong as to err is human but the consistency, obviousness and timing of the decisions wa
RE:Australia did u deserve this ..... :X !
by Vimal Goel on Jan 06, 2008 01:53 PM Permalink
all's fine but what happens o our batsman's when the necessity arrive. They shud have app;ied and faced everything with comfort and rather stretch for victory.
I am sure Had this aus team been in india's position, they wud be thinking of winning the game. Ganguly was dropped, dravid was dropped.
As far as umpiring goes, i have seemn venkat raghavan giving worst of LBW's in kumble's favour when the bowl has pitched outside leg.
Here it was one way traffic, thats fine but still we are no match to aussies in any condition.
RE:Australia did u deserve this ..... :X !
by VenkataChandraSekhar Alluri on Jan 06, 2008 02:08 PM Permalink
Hi Vimal, here discussion in on umpiring. I accept there were some bad decisions given in the past by Venkat Ragavan. BUt after the yell on those decisions, he has retired from the job.
Here, cricket is sufferring buckner from lats couple of years.
Coming to your statement, we are no match to aussies, i totally disagree with u.
At the start of 1983 world cup, no team is match to West Indies. BUt after that great win by India, West Indies is out of Top Team Slot.
Team India played brilliantly today and as a team. My hat goes out to every player in the team regardless of what they scored, cos they tried as hard as they could. Even RP was not out as his decision was very marginal and benefiot should have gone to him. The only thing Indian fans should remember is this test, and make sure the next time they see Aussie cricketers back in India make it a living hell for them. Lets not Forget this insult.
RE:Lets not Forget
by pradeep dhillon on Jan 06, 2008 01:58 PM Permalink
you are absolutely right rakesh....i along with every other indian is seething inside with tremendous anger !! I firmly believe ...either the result of this match be cancelled or india return back.there is no point playing with these cheaters and idiots..! And when australia tour india...give them a time of their lives which they never forget till they reach their graves !
India has to complain. Not only to complain, they have to boycot the next 2 test matches and come back to India. When 2 teams playing and fighting for pride, you cant have so many controversal decisions.
India might have saved the match if Dravid and Ganguly were not given out. How can the umpire ask a fielder whether you caught it or not? How can you trust a fielder, not the batsman who stood his ground. In dravid's case, Nothing touched and that blind Steve Bucknor gave his out. Wasim jaffer is clean biowled on a No Ball.
how can be all wrong decisions will be against India?
This is an offical match fixing. if this continues, Aus can win consecutive 40 matches.
RE:BOYCOTT
by Rakesh Narayan on Jan 06, 2008 01:38 PM Permalink
This match was totally rigged, and its a shame no neutral commentator is standing against it. I suspect the strongest critic is going to be our Steve Waugh. Hes the only Aussie with class.
Cangaru's just want to make world record for winning 17 match in row.They could do any thing to win the match even They can acquire or buy umpires for that.this is worst cricket from Australia.
