RE:australians are champions
by Sunil Kumar on Jan 06, 2008 03:14 PM Permalink
And also they have the terrorists and controversy mongers. These help in psychologically subduing the other team and thus winning the game. They have 14 plus the devils with them.
It was very very very...... bad umbiring. Things indicated that Aussies and Cricket Australia fixing the matches by purchasing the umbires for their winning streaj to go. This is not a good win. Mr. Ponting this matches you have not deserved for win. Buth the umbires deserved for australia to win the match in favour of aussies. Aussies can't win even single match without the help of umbires.
I think the third should be brought into picture here and he should be given a right to nullify the decisions of the umpires if in replays he finds the decisions were wrong. I think this would help to a large extent the cricket to progress further. Barring LBWs, the other decisions can be handled better by the third umpire. As both teams would benefit from the decisions, no one wil complain.
RE:THIRD UMPIRE ...
by preeti lokesh on Jan 06, 2008 03:24 PM Permalink
It all rubbish to discuss now.To tell you, indian tie lenders, could not play 8 balls.Why we indians are so nervous and emotional.We are not fighting from our freedom there.Two ro three balls if we hit by their heads, when they r in closest fielding. Really great coursge by Kumble, keep his character whole match.Such 11 players required for India to play against smart, crucked, hard woking racial aussies team. Few ecisions against us,would really costed us a lot.It looks umpires working for aussies and Ricky ponting dictating them.During the match, y Ricky ponting speaks no.of times with umpire.Really there must be a rule that umpires should not talk to players on field. BCCI must lodge a complaint against umpiring. Comeon India!! wake up, and bring Sehwag into team. thanks
It is better our selectors introspect themselves than pointing towards umpires.For the sake of yuvaraj they created chaos in batting order and also selecting yuvaraj ahead of sehwag for the 2nd test which really costed India. It is better to ban jaffer, yuvaraj and selectors.
RE:RE:Blame&FIre selectors instead of umpires
by ssdsd asas on Jan 06, 2008 03:12 PM Permalink
oye girlzgirlz, plzz don't mix the issues dude..this was terrible umpiring...yuvi's performance is a totally separate topic..BTW in perth we do need him
RE:Blame&FIre selectors instead of umpires
by rashmin hathi on Jan 06, 2008 03:18 PM Permalink
Pahele ye batao tum Indian ho to fir gali empire ko do yuvi ko nahi.
Physical address: International Cricket Council Al Thuraya Tower 1, 11th floor Dubai Media City Dubai United Arab Emirates By post: The International Cricket Council P.O.Box 500070 Dubai United Arab Emirates
By phone or fax: Tel: 971 4 368 8300 Fax: 971 4 368 8080
Aussies did not deserve to win the match.. 7 Bad decision went against India , well one bad decision is enough to change the whole match.. I appeal to CHECK THE BANK ACCOUNTS OF STEVE BUCKNOR & MARK BENSON ... IS THERE ANY SUDDEN INCREASE IN ACCOUNT OR ANY MATCH FIXING b/w UMPIRES & RICKY PONTING.. JUST LOOK AT THE PONTING REACTION JUST AFTER GANGULY GOT OUT,IT WILL TELL THE WHOLE STORY
RE:Bucknor was the best ump some years back. But i guess he should take a back seat now. The other ump was absolute ass.!!
by on Jan 06, 2008 03:11 PM Permalink
Why are you insulting an ass!
RE:Bucknor was the best ump some years back. But i guess he should take a back seat now. The other ump was absolute ass.!!
by sandeep on Jan 06, 2008 03:13 PM Permalink
hey ... but there was some suffix after the 'ass' as well .... couldnt be too explicit
We simply can not criticize the umpire's alone, because now a days the umpires are put under tremendous pressure by the television replay's, media's and by the players.
If a batsman knows very well that he has nicked the ball, he should walk straight away and should make the umpire job more easier or Sometimes when the ball pitched on the leg side he should not appeal. If he fails to do so, the player should be banned for some matches and that ban should be decide by the current touring opposite team (The opposite team can make that player sit out during the important matches).
Also the third or the fourth umpires also should intervene when the field umpires go wrong with the decisions.
RE:On Umpires and players....
by cool on Jan 06, 2008 03:23 PM Permalink
Mahesh all these alternative methods of giving a decision come to the fore only when the umpires in the middle dont do their job well..!! SO as long as we have incompetent,old,grumphy,biased,useless,rigid umpires like bucknor and benson people will always have to be at their creative best and think of ways to make sure we remove the errors from the game..! What happens if the 3rd umpire is also someone like bucknor.. Who misses a stumping of "monkey phobic" symonds?What do we do then... I say cancel the tour and play pakistan again...!!
RE:On Umpires and players....
by Aussie Ki Taise on Jan 06, 2008 03:14 PM Permalink
hello if u see the match...most decisions r favorable to australia...and australian were give white man's treatment and we indians r treated as slaved...
aussie stoop to all time low ..even appealed to a bump ball
What a bloody disgrace.Benson Bucknor have gone a long way to spoil a good game of cricket. A really waste of space, ICC please get rid of Bucknor, has something against India. Have noticed for a while now. Conrad Conway Australia.
