Pathan is one of the kye player of the Indian team. His back to India is may cause serious demorolization of Indian team. He is not only the bowler like Munaff Patel, Jahir khan etc. but we must care his batting porfomenc too. If he is not playing well then we should do all this thing after toure because it may obiously blome his confidence if we calling him in the middle of the match.
It may be a right decision to send Pathan back to home after his dismal performance.As the idea is not to punish him but let him come out the bad patches of his life.But by the same philisophy Sehawag and Jaffer should also come back particularly Sehwag who has poor outing in S.Africa.As a matter of fact his game is suffering through out the year.As per the standards of expectations from a senior player like him he is not able to deliever even the performance of an average player.He too needs some time to recuperate.
Pathan has capabilities which he has proved - he is out of form for the moment - that shd NOT mean sending him back in the middle of a series!! Why doesn't BCCI hv the guts to send back Tendulkar? B'cos he runs indian cricket behind the back. Its all about money / politics..... at the end of the day.
its really disappointed. if sehwag can paly in the team than why not irfy. irfan much better than sehwag now. no body play nice againts south africa only irfy can bat he made 111 not out , 15 not out etc in practice match. even one bats men din't made this.
As WORLD CUP is Cumming. And Irfan is one of the key playe . To send back him is not a good decision,it will shetter playe confinence. Istead of sending him back they have to played in India XI In 3 Days Match